When launching a startup, one of the most important early decisions is choosing a business ownership structure. The structure you select will impact everything from your personal legal liability to tax obligations, fundraising ability, and the ease of day-to-day operations. In the United States, founders typically choose from several common business structures: sole proprietorship, partnership (general or limited), limited liability company (LLC), C corporation, S corporation, and in some cases nonprofit corporation. Each type has distinct advantages, disadvantages, and legal/tax implications. This guide will explain each structure in detail – including definitions, key pros and cons, tax treatment, liability considerations, and what kinds of startups they suit best – and provide a comparison table to summarize the differences.
Why does this decision matter? Your business structure affects how much you pay in taxes, what kind of paperwork and compliance you face, your ability to raise capital, and the degree to which your personal assets are protected from business debts. While you can change your structure later, doing so can be complicated or have tax consequences. It’s worth taking the time to understand your options now. Let’s dive into each structure so you can make an informed choice for your startup.
|
Table of Contents |
A sole proprietorship is the simplest form of business – it’s essentially an unincorporated business owned and run by one individual. If you start doing business by yourself and don’t formally register as any other type of entity, you’re automatically considered a sole proprietorship by default. There is no separate legal entity created, meaning the business and the owner are one and the same in the eyes of the law. All business assets and liabilities are tied directly to the owner’s personal assets and liabilities.
Because there’s no legal distinction between owner and business, the sole proprietor has complete control over the business and keeps all the profits – but also bears unlimited personal liability for any debts or legal obligations . For example, if the business can’t pay its bills or is sued, the owner’s personal assets (house, car, bank accounts, etc.) could be at risk to satisfy business debts. There is no liability shield in a sole proprietorship.
For tax purposes, a sole proprietorship’s income is reported on the owner’s personal return. The profit or loss is calculated on Schedule C (Profit or Loss from Business) and flows into the Form 1040. You’ll pay ordinary income tax on any profits, plus self-employment tax for Social Security/Medicare if your net earnings are $400 or more. There’s no separate business income tax return. One advantage is avoiding corporate tax; income is only taxed once (to you personally). However, you also cannot split income with others (unless you hire employees or contractors as expenses) – all the profit is yours and taxed as such. It’s wise to set aside money for quarterly estimated tax payments, since taxes aren’t withheld as they would be on a paycheck.
As mentioned, the sole proprietor has no liability protection. If your startup faces a lawsuit or defaults on a debt, you’re on the hook personally. This is acceptable for some low-risk ventures or side hustles, but it’s a serious consideration. Many founders start as sole proprietors to test an idea, but switch to an LLC or corporation if the business begins to grow or face meaningful risk ). If you remain a sole proprietor, ensure you have adequate insurance (e.g. liability insurance) to mitigate some risk, since legally the business offers no shield.
Sole proprietorships are best for low-risk, small-scale businesses and solo entrepreneurs testing the waters. If you’re starting a one-person consulting practice, freelancing, or selling a product on a small scale, it’s a quick way to start operating. It’s also common as a temporary or preliminary structure – e.g. two co-founders might each be sole proprietors doing business together informally before formalizing a partnership or LLC. However, if you plan to seek investors, hire a team, or if your business has liability exposure, you’ll likely need to move beyond a sole proprietorship. Think of it as a starter structure for very early-stage or one-person ventures.
If two or more individuals (or businesses) decide to own a business together without forming an LLC or corporation, they are operating as a partnership. A partnership is an unincorporated business with multiple owners, and it comes in a few flavors. The two most common are the general partnership (GP) and the limited partnership (LP). There are also limited liability partnerships (LLPs) used mostly by certain professionals, which we’ll mention shortly. In any partnership, each co-owner is termed a partner.
In a general partnership, all partners share in management and profits, and crucially, all partners have unlimited personal liability for the business’s debts and legal obligations . This means each general partner can bind the partnership (e.g., take on a debt or sign a contract), and every partner is personally liable for the obligations incurred – even if caused by another partner’s actions . For example, if one partner makes a bad deal or a negligent mistake, all partners’ personal assets could be on the line to satisfy resulting debts or judgments.
Forming a GP is extremely simple – no state filing is required to form a general partnership (it can arise by default when two or more people carry on a business together for profit). It’s wise, however, to have a written partnership agreement outlining each partner’s rights and responsibilities and what happens if someone leaves, as partnerships can otherwise be fragile. In the absence of an agreement, state partnership laws will dictate default rules (often splitting profits 50/50, etc.)
A limited partnership is a partnership with two classes of partners: at least one general partner and one or more limited partners. The general partner (GP) in an LP has the same role as in a general partnership – they manage the business and have unlimited personal liability for partnership debts . The limited partners (LPs) are essentially investors who contribute capital and share in profits, but have limited liability – their personal liability is capped at the amount of their investment in the business. In exchange for this liability protection, limited partners are not allowed to actively manage the business; they are often called “silent partners”. If a limited partner starts taking an active management role, they could risk losing their limited liability status under the law.
Forming a limited partnership is more involved than a GP. State registration is required – typically filing a Certificate of Limited Partnership with the Secretary of State . The business name usually must include an LP designation (like “XYZ Limited Partnership”) to put the public on notice of the limited partner arrangement . An LP also needs a partnership agreement delineating the roles of general vs. limited partners, profit shares, etc. In many states, limited partnerships and other entities now must also file a beneficial ownership information report under new federal regulations (FinCEN) to disclose who owns and controls the entity – this is a recent compliance requirement as of 2024.
A quick note on LLPs – an LLP is essentially a general partnership where all partners have at least some liability protection (often protecting partners from debts or negligence claims arising from other partners’ actions). LLPs are primarily used by licensed professional firms – e.g. groups of attorneys, accountants, architects – in states where such professionals can’t form an LLC but are allowed to register as an LLP. In an LLP, each partner is not personally liable for the malpractice of other partners (so one lawyer isn’t on the hook if another lawyer in the firm is sued for malpractice). However, partners typically remain liable for their own negligence or wrongdoing. The LLP is formed by filing with the state, and not all states permit all businesses to be LLPs (often it’s restricted to professional practices). For most startup founders, LLPs are not applicable unless you’re starting a professional services firm. The tax treatment of LLPs is the same as any partnership (pass-through), and all partners can be involved in management. Essentially, an LLP tries to offer the liability shield of an LLC while retaining the flexibility of a partnership, within specific fields.
All partnerships (GP, LP, LLP) are taxed as pass-through entities by default. The partnership files an informational tax return (Form 1065) each year and provides each partner with a Schedule K-1 reporting that partner’s share of income, deductions, and credits . The partners then include that information on their personal tax returns (Form 1040). The income is taxed at each partner’s individual income tax rates. The partnership itself does not pay federal income tax. One nuance: general partners (and LLP partners, who are active) pay self-employment tax on their share of earnings, while limited partners generally do not pay self-employment tax on their passive income share. This can be advantageous for limited partners. Partnerships can also elect to allocate income and losses in special ways via the partnership agreement, but those allocations must have economic substance and follow IRS rules. Also note, partners are not considered employees, so they are not on payroll – they generally take draws or distributions of profit (and perhaps guaranteed payments for services). This means no withholding – partners might need to pay estimated taxes quarterly.
To summarize, in a general partnership, every partner faces unlimited personal liability (and mutual liability for each other’s actions). In a limited partnership, the general partner(s) have unlimited liability, whereas limited partners have liability only up to their investment (as long as they remain passive). In an LLP, all partners typically get protection from debts arising from other partners’ actions, but usually not from their own malpractice or personal guarantees (. None of these partnership forms provides the full, blanket liability shield that a corporation or LLC does, but LPs and LLPs do mitigate certain risks. Founders should carefully consider the liability exposure, and many avoid general partnerships unless they fully trust their partners and have low-risk activities. Insurance can help manage some risk in partnerships too, but it’s not a complete solution.
Partnerships can be a good choice for multiple-owner businesses that value simplicity and direct pass-through taxation. A general partnership might be suitable for a small group of co-founders who are testing a concept and want to avoid upfront filing costs – especially if the venture is low-risk or short-term. It’s also common in professional service firms (sometimes as an LLP) where partners want flexibility. However, due to liability, many startups outgrow the GP phase quickly if they gain traction. Limited partnerships are suited for scenarios where you have a mix of active and passive partners – for example, a startup where one person or entity will run the business (and is willing to take on liability) and others are purely investors. Typical tech or product startups rarely use LPs, but you do see LPs in investment funds, film or arts projects, or oil & gas ventures. If your startup is essentially an investment vehicle or a project financed by backers who won’t be involved in operations, an LP could be useful. Otherwise, most startup founders lean towards LLCs or corporations for liability protection once the business is more than just an idea.
A Limited Liability Company (LLC) is an extremely popular choice for many startups and small businesses. An LLC is a unique hybrid structure that combines elements of a corporation’s liability protection with the flexibility and tax advantages of a partnership. In legal terms, an LLC is a separate legal entity formed under state law, which means it can own property, incur debts, sue and be sued in its own name, separating the business from the owners (members). The owners of an LLC are called members, and there can be one member (single-member LLC) or many members (multi-member LLC).
One of the primary benefits of an LLC is that it shields the owners’ personal assets from business liabilities. In most cases, members are not personally liable for the debts or legal obligations of the company – the LLC itself is responsible. If the LLC defaults on a loan or faces a lawsuit, generally the owners’ personal assets are protected; only the assets of the business are at stake. (Members can, however, lose their investment in the company, and there are exceptions if, for example, an owner personally guarantees a loan or engages in fraud.) This liability protection is illustrated below – essentially a “wall” between personal assets and business creditors.
Why Choose an LLC?An LLC provides a liability barrier between your personal assets (home, car, savings) and your business’s obligations, helping protect the owner’s personal property in case of business debts or lawsuits . This limited liability feature is one of the main reasons entrepreneurs choose the LLC structure. |
Beyond liability protection, LLCs offer flexibility in taxation. By default, a single-member LLC is disregarded as an entity for tax purposes (treated like a sole proprietorship) and a multi-member LLC is taxed like a partnership. In either case, the income passes through to the owner(s)’ personal tax returns – avoiding a corporate tax layer. However, LLCs also have the option to elect to be taxed as a corporation (either a C corporation or, if eligible, as an S corporation) by filing the appropriate forms with the IRS . This flexibility allows the owners to choose the tax treatment that best suits their situation. Many LLCs stick with pass-through taxation, but some will elect S-corp status to reduce self-employment taxes, or even C-corp status if they plan to retain earnings or seek certain tax benefits.
LLCs are formed at the state level by filing Articles of Organization (sometimes called a Certificate of Organization) with the state’s business filing office (usually the Secretary of State). You also pay a filing fee (which varies by state, typically $50–$500). The LLC’s operating rules are usually outlined in an Operating Agreement (though this document is not always legally required, it’s highly recommended). The Operating Agreement sets out how the LLC is managed, how profits and losses are shared, how members can enter or exit, and so on. LLCs can be member-managed (run directly by the owners) or manager-managed (owners appoint one or more managers, who could be members or outside persons, to run the business). This flexibility allows a structure tailored to the business’s needs.
LLC members are not personally liable for the company’s obligations in most instances. This is a huge advantage over sole proprietorships and partnerships. It’s important to note that limited liability isn’t absolute – if an owner personally injures someone or commits a personal wrongdoing, they are still personally liable for that act (you can’t hide personal torts behind an LLC). But for contracts and business debts, the LLC structure provides a shield. Also, if an owner signs a personal guarantee for a loan or lease, that contractual agreement bypasses the LLC protection for that obligation. Overall, though, an LLC properly operated provides strong protection: creditors of the business can normally only go after business assets, not the owners’ houses or savings. This is why LLC stands for “Limited Liability Company” – it’s right in the name.
LLCs are often an excellent choice for small to medium-sized startups that want liability protection and tax flexibility but don’t need to raise money from VC investors in the immediate future. They work well for family businesses, consultancies, tech startups in early stages, real estate ventures, and more. Many startups begin as LLCs during the initial development or friends-and-family funding stage. If and when the company decides to take on institutional investment or convert to a C-corp (for example, to issue stock options to employees or attract VC funding), the LLC can usually be converted through a legal process (which may have some tax implications to plan for).
For bootstrapped startups or those seeking only smaller investors, an LLC can provide a good balance of simplicity and protection. International founders often prefer LLCs if they cannot meet S-corp citizenship requirements or if they want a flexible structure. In cases where maximum growth and going public is the vision, founders might skip the LLC and go straight to a C-corp. But for many new businesses, the LLC offers a flexible, protective, and relatively straightforward structure to start with, and it remains extremely popular for that reason.
When people refer to “incorporating” or a business being a “Inc.” or “Corp.”, they are usually talking about a C Corporation. A C corporation (named for Subchapter C of the IRS code) is a classic corporate structure: a legal entity separate from its owners (shareholders), with its own rights and obligations. A corporation can make profits, incur debts, sue and be sued, and continue in existence independent of any particular owner. This structure is well-known for providing strong liability protection for owners – shareholders generally are not personally liable for corporate debts or lawsuits; they can only lose the money they invested in the stock.
Key features of a C corp include a potential for unlimited growth and investment. A C corporation can issue stock to an unlimited number of shareholders, and even multiple classes of stock (such as common and preferred shares) . This ability to sell equity stakes makes it the preferred structure for startups seeking venture capital or planning an IPO (initial public offering). Most major companies and high-growth startups are C corps. C corps also have a perpetual life – the departure or death of a shareholder does not impede the corporation’s continuity. Ownership can be easily transferred by selling shares, and the corporation goes on.
However, C corporations are unique among the structures discussed here in that they face double taxation of profits in many cases. A C corp is a taxable entity – it files its own corporate tax return (Form 1120) and pays corporate income tax on its profits at the federal level (21% rate as of recent years), plus any applicable state corporate taxes. Then, if the corporation distributes some of those profits to shareholders as dividends, the shareholders pay income tax on those dividends on their personal returns. Essentially, the money can be taxed once at the corporate level and again at the individual level. This double taxation is often cited as a disadvantage, especially for small businesses. (There are ways earnings can be returned to owners without dividend double-tax, like salaries or expense reimbursements, but pure profits left after corporate tax will be taxed if distributed.)
Forming a C corporation requires filing Articles of Incorporation (sometimes called a Certificate of Incorporation or Charter) with the state, and paying the incorporation fees. The owners (initial shareholders) typically adopt bylaws (rules for operating the corporation) and hold an initial meeting to elect a Board of Directors. The corporation must also issue stock to the owners (even if it’s just a few shares to the founders initially) to formalize ownership. Because of these steps, formation is more costly and complex than forming an LLC or partnership – often legal assistance is used to do it properly, especially for setting up a startup with multiple founders and stock allocation. Many startups choose to incorporate in business-friendly jurisdictions like Delaware (even if they operate elsewhere) due to well-developed corporate laws and investor preferences.
A C corporation files a tax return (Form 1120) and pays corporate income tax on its taxable income. The federal corporate tax rate is a flat 21% as of 2025. State corporate tax rates vary (commonly ~4–10%). If the corporation distributes profits as dividends, shareholders pay tax on those dividends at the dividend tax rate (qualified dividends are typically taxed at long-term capital gains rates, e.g., 15% or 20% depending on income, plus possibly a 3.8% net investment income tax). So, a profitable C corp that pays dividends will result in a combined tax bite higher than a pass-through entity. If the corporation retains earnings for growth, then shareholders aren’t immediately taxed on those retained earnings (but the corporation has paid its tax). When a shareholder sells their stock at a gain, they pay capital gains tax on the appreciation. One notable tax benefit: as mentioned, if the corporation qualifies as a Qualified Small Business (Section 1202) C Corp, and stock is held >5 years, the shareholder can potentially exclude 100% of the gain on the sale of stock (up to certain limits), which is a major tax perk for startups that become very valuable. This only applies to C corp stock (not S corp or LLC interests) in certain industries and with certain size limitations, but many tech startups qualify. Also, C corps can deduct state and local taxes fully as a business expense (whereas pass-through owners are subject to SALT deduction limits on their personal returns), which in high-tax states could be an advantage at the entity level. In summary, for tax: double taxation is the downside, potential tax planning and special breaks are the nuanced upside. Many startups initially don’t have profits (only losses), so early on the corporate taxation isn’t a big issue; the losses can carry forward within the corporation to offset future profits (but those losses don’t help the owners’ personal taxes, unlike in an LLC/S-corp where initial losses could pass through).
A C corporation provides very strong liability protection. Shareholders’ personal assets are not reachable by corporate creditors or lawsuit claimants. Only the money invested in the company (and the company’s own assets) are at risk. There are rare exceptions: if a court finds the corporation was just a sham (e.g., owners commingled funds, undercapitalized the company intentionally to defraud, or failed to follow any corporate formalities), it may pierce the corporate veil and hold owners personally liable. But this is uncommon when the corporation is operated properly. Additionally, officers and directors can be personally liable in certain situations (like if they breach fiduciary duties or for certain unpaid taxes or if they personally guarantee debts). But as a baseline, the corporation is one of the best shields between your business and personal finances.
C corporations are typically the go-to structure for startups aiming to scale, attract significant outside investment, or eventually go public. If you are seeking venture capital, planning rapid growth, issuing stock options to employees, or just want the maximum flexibility for expanding ownership, a C corp (often a Delaware C corp for U.S. startups) is the standard. Tech startups in Silicon Valley, for example, overwhelmingly are Delaware C corporations from an early stage specifically to align with investor expectations. Even if you’re not looking for VC, if you want a very formal structure and might seek other institutional investors or complex equity arrangements, a C corp is appropriate.
On the other hand, if you are running a small business or a closely-held company that will not seek external investors and will distribute most profits to a small group of owners, a C corp is usually not as advantageous – an S corp or LLC would often be better to avoid double taxes. Some founders choose a C corp form anyway for other reasons (possible Section 1202 gain exclusion, or the simplicity of clearly separate business taxation). Ultimately, for a startup that envisions “big” things – high growth, multiple investment rounds, possible IPO or acquisition – the C corporation is often the best choice despite the extra complexity, because it facilitates those goals (and most sophisticated investors will insist on it). For more modest startups, the C corp may be overkill.
An S Corporation (or S corp) is not a different type of entity per se, but a special tax designation that a corporation (or in some cases an LLC) can elect with the IRS. When people talk about an S corp, they usually mean a corporation that has filed for S status. The key feature of an S corp is that it elects to be treated as a pass-through entity for tax purposes, under Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code. In practice, this means an S corporation avoids corporate income tax; instead, the company’s profits and losses are passed through directly to shareholders’ personal tax returns (similar to a partnership), thereby avoiding the double taxation that C corps face.
However, to get these tax benefits, S corps must adhere to strict eligibility criteria and ongoing requirements. Not every corporation can or should be an S corp. The IRS rules for S corporations include: the corporation can have no more than 100 shareholders, and all shareholders must be U.S. citizens or residents (no non-resident aliens). The corporation can only have one class of stock (meaning all shares have identical economic rights; you can’t have preferred stock with special preferences). Shareholders must generally be individuals (or certain trusts or estates; other corporations or partnerships cannot be shareholders). Additionally, certain businesses like banks, insurance companies, or international sales corporations are not eligible for S corp status. The corporation must be a U.S. domestic corporation. To elect S status, all shareholders must consent, and you file IRS Form 2553 (usually within a couple months of formation or the start of a tax year).
An S corp is first and foremost a corporation at the state level – so you form a corporation (with the same steps and formalities as a C corp), then make the S election for tax. In terms of legal characteristics, an S corp is basically the same as a C corp (limited liability for owners, the same state law corporate structure, etc.). The differences are in taxation and some limitations on ownership structure due to the IRS rules.
S corporations do not pay federal income tax at the entity level. Instead, they file an informational tax return (Form 1120S) and issue Schedule K-1 to each shareholder indicating their share of the company’s income, deductions, credits, etc. Shareholders report that on their personal returns and pay tax at their individual rates . The income retains some character – for example, certain corporate gains might flow as capital gains, etc., but generally it’s taxed as ordinary income to the owners. Shareholder-employees must be paid a salary, which is a deductible expense to the S corp (reducing pass-through profit) and then taxed via payroll to the owner. Any remaining profit is distributed or left in the company but still allocated to owners for tax. Unlike a C corp, S corp income is taxed whether or not it’s distributed (like a partnership, owners are taxed on their share even if they left it in the business bank account). For this reason, S corps usually distribute enough cash to cover owners’ tax liabilities at minimum. In terms of rates: shareholders pay federal income tax (which could be up to 37% for high income individuals) plus any state tax on their share of S corp profits, but they do not pay self-employment tax on distributions (only on their salary portion). Some states, as mentioned, levy a small corporate tax or fee on S corps (for instance, California charges 1.5% tax on net income of S corps, minimum $800, even while it passes the rest to owners). Overall, the tax outcome is typically more favorable than a C corp for small-to-moderate profit levels that will be distributed. Also, the pass-through income might qualify for the 20% QBI deduction if under income limits and not a disqualified business type (. S corp status can be revoked (either voluntarily or by violation) – if that happens, the corporation becomes a C corp and will be taxed accordingly (and generally you have to wait 5 years to elect S again once you lose it).
Legally, an S corp is just a corporation. So, the limited liability protection is the same as a C corp – owners (shareholders) are not personally liable for business debts or legal judgments beyond their investment. The corporate veil protects personal assets, assuming corporate formalities are observed. There’s no difference in liability whether your corporation is an S or C for tax; that doesn’t change the corporate law. So an S corp shields you just as effectively as any corporation or LLC. As always, directors/officers could have certain liabilities, and personally guaranteed debts or direct personal torts are exceptions, but generally the protection is robust.
S corporations are well-suited for small, closely-held companies that are (or will be) profitable and want to distribute income to owners in a tax-efficient way, while still enjoying the legal benefits of a corporation. Many family businesses or closely-held companies with U.S. citizen owners choose S corp. It’s also common for professional businesses (consultancies, agencies, etc.) once they grow beyond a one-person LLC to elect S status to save on taxes. If you are a startup with just a few U.S. founders and perhaps some U.S. angel investors, and you don’t anticipate needing institutional capital soon, an S corp can be a good structure: you get the liability protection and credibility of a corporation, with single-layer taxation.
However, if you plan to seek venture capital, bring on foreign investors or co-founders, or need to grant stock options widely, an S corp won’t work due to its restrictions. Those startups either skip S corp or later convert to C corp (indeed, many companies that start as S corps switch to C corp when scaling up). Another scenario: sometimes an LLC that is growing will convert to an S corp (or an LLC will elect to be taxed as an S corp) once the net income is high enough that self-employment taxes become painful – this way, the owners can take part of the earnings as distributions. This is a common tax-planning move for small businesses. In summary, an S corp is a great middle-ground for businesses that want the best of both worlds (corporate form + pass-through taxes) within the limitations set by the IRS. It fits a lot of small business models, but not the hyper-growth startup model.
A Nonprofit Corporation is a special type of corporation organized not to make profits for owners, but to further a charitable, educational, religious, or public service mission. In a nonprofit (often called a not-for-profit), any income earned is reinvested in the organization’s programs and operations; profits cannot be distributed to individuals or shareholders. Nonprofit corporations are eligible to apply for tax-exempt status – for example, charitable nonprofits can apply to the IRS for recognition as a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization (named after the section of the tax code). If approved, the nonprofit is exempt from federal income tax (and often state income tax) on money it earns related to its charitable purpose. Donors to 501(c)(3) nonprofits may also get a tax deduction for their contributions.
Structurally, a nonprofit corporation is formed by filing Articles of Incorporation at the state level (similar to a regular corporation). Instead of shareholders, a nonprofit is typically governed by a Board of Directors or Trustees. It may have members (some nonprofits have a membership structure where members have certain voting rights, somewhat analogous to shareholders but without ownership equity). The nonprofit must state a specific purpose that aligns with one of the categories allowed (charitable, educational, scientific, religious, etc.). It must also adopt bylaws and follow corporate formalities. Upon dissolution, any remaining assets must be given to another tax-exempt entity or government (not to private individuals).
No owners and no profit distribution: By definition, a nonprofit has no owners/shareholders who can benefit from profits. Any surplus the organization generates has to be plowed back into the organization’s mission. The directors and officers can receive reasonable compensation for their work, but they can’t pocket profits as dividends or sell the company for a windfall. This fundamental difference makes the nonprofit unsuitable for anyone looking to build a company for financial gain. It is aimed at missions for the public good.
Limited liability: Like other corporations, a nonprofit corporation provides liability protection to its directors, officers, and members. They are generally not personally liable for the debts or lawsuits of the nonprofit. (They do have fiduciary duties to the nonprofit and can be sued if they violate those duties or engage in wrongdoing, but they won’t be on the hook for the nonprofit’s contractual obligations just by virtue of being on the board.) This allows people to serve as directors or run the nonprofit without risking personal assets, which is important for attracting qualified people to charitable endeavors.
Tax-exempt status (if approved): The big advantage – if the nonprofit qualifies under IRS rules (and state rules), it can be exempt from income tax on its charitable activities. For example, a nonprofit hospital or a charity doesn’t pay federal income tax on donations or service revenue that furthers its exempt purpose. This means more of its resources go to its programs rather than taxes. Additionally, many nonprofits are exempt from state and local taxes (like property tax or sales tax) in some cases, and can qualify for postal discounts, etc. Achieving 501(c)(3) status also allows donors to deduct contributions on their tax returns, which encourages fundraising. To get this status, the nonprofit must file an application (Form 1023 or 1023-EZ) with the IRS and meet stringent requirements. It’s not automatic – just incorporating as a nonprofit at the state level doesn’t give federal tax exemption. It’s a separate federal (and sometimes state) process with detailed paperwork.
Purpose and compliance constraints: Nonprofits are restricted in their purpose and activities. They must operate within the scope of their stated mission and for the public benefit. They also face limits on political activities (e.g., a 501(c)(3) cannot engage in partisan political campaigning and can only do limited lobbying). They must avoid “private inurement”, meaning they can’t funnel profits or unreasonable compensation to insiders. Each year, tax-exempt nonprofits have to file a detailed information return (Form 990 series) with the IRS, publicly reporting their finances and operations. This transparency is required and allows the public to hold nonprofits accountable. The nonprofit also must adhere to corporate governance similar to a C corp – holding board meetings, keeping minutes, following its bylaws – as well as the special nonprofit rules. If a nonprofit strays from the rules (for instance, giving profits to insiders or engaging in significant unrelated commercial activity), it can lose its tax-exempt status.
Formation and ongoing complexity: Starting a nonprofit corporation is more complex than a regular corporation in some ways. The incorporation itself is similar (though you often include specific tax-exempt language in your charter). But the critical step is obtaining tax-exempt status, which can be a lengthy process (the IRS application for 501(c)(3) can be hundreds of pages including narrative descriptions, financial forecasts, etc., unless you qualify for a streamlined version). Legal expertise is often needed to set it up properly. Ongoing, nonprofits have a high compliance burden: annual IRS and state filings, maintaining detailed records of how funds are used, and fulfilling public reporting obligations. This overhead is worthwhile for charitable endeavors, but it’s not trivial.
No equity or sale value: Because a nonprofit has no owners, you can’t sell a nonprofit or take it public. If you start a nonprofit, you effectively “give it away” to the public – even though you might control it via the board initially, the assets must always be used for the nonprofit’s purposes. If the organization dissolves, whatever assets remain after debts must go to another nonprofit or charity, not to any individual. Founders of nonprofits therefore do not have an equity stake they can cash out. They may draw a salary if employed by the nonprofit, but that’s it. This is a huge difference from a for-profit startup.
If the nonprofit corporation obtains 501(c)(3) (or another 501(c)) status, it generally does not pay income tax on revenue related to its exempt purpose. For example, donations, grants, membership fees, or program service revenue that align with its mission are tax-exempt. However, if the nonprofit has unrelated business income (UBI) – money from activities not substantially related to its mission – it may have to pay unrelated business income tax (UBIT) on that. Nonprofits do still pay payroll taxes for any employees (having tax-exemption doesn’t excuse you from withholding and paying Social Security, Medicare, etc., on wages). Donors to charitable nonprofits can deduct donations on their personal taxes, which is an important funding consideration. Nonprofits must file an annual Form 990 (for larger ones) or 990-EZ or 990-N (for smaller) with the IRS, which is a public record of their finances and activities. Failing to file for 3 years results in loss of exemption. If a nonprofit does not obtain tax-exempt status, it could still operate but then it’s taxed like a regular corporation (but still without profit distribution). Most seek the exemption if eligible.
A nonprofit corporation’s directors and officers have limited liability like their for-profit counterparts. One difference is that many states have laws providing additional protections for volunteer directors of nonprofits, reducing their personal liability as long as they act in good faith (to encourage people to serve on nonprofit boards without fear). Day-to-day, the nonprofit is liable for its debts; board members or founders aren’t personally liable, except in cases of fraud or breach of duty. Volunteers and employees are typically protected as well, though they can be personally liable if they themselves cause harm (like any person would). The nonprofit can buy insurance (like Directors & Officers insurance) to further protect those involved.
A nonprofit corporation is only suitable if your startup’s primary aim is charitable or public service, rather than profit. Examples might be if you’re launching a charitable startup – say, a new educational platform that will operate as a charity relying on grants and donations, or a social venture where you intend to reinvest all earnings into the cause and possibly seek tax-deductible contributions. Some organizations blur lines (like social enterprises or B-Corps, which are for-profit but mission-driven; note that a Benefit Corporation or B-Corp is different – it’s a for-profit structure with a public benefit focus, but not tax-exempt). If you truly don’t intend to ever distribute profits and want tax-exempt benefits, the nonprofit route might be the way to go.
For most startup founders with a business idea aimed at making money, a nonprofit is not appropriate – you would be tying your hands from ever taking a profit or equity out. But if the goal is philanthropic (like developing open-source technology for the public good, or providing free services to a community), a nonprofit corporation could be the right structure. Keep in mind, starting a nonprofit means giving up the idea of personal financial upside; your reward is in achieving the mission. There are also hybrid models (like forming a nonprofit arm and a for-profit arm), but that gets complicated. In summary, choose a nonprofit only if your startup is mission-first and you’re okay with strict reinvestment of earnings and oversight.
Now that we’ve broken down each structure, the following table provides a side-by-side comparison of key differences in ownership, liability, taxation, formation, and compliance for these common business forms. This can serve as a handy reference to distinguish the options:
|
Structure |
Ownership |
Liability Protection |
Tax Treatment |
Formation Complexity |
Ongoing Compliance |
|
Sole Proprietorship |
Individual |
None |
Pass-Through |
Very Low |
Low |
|
General Partnership |
Two or more partners |
None |
Pass-Through |
Low |
Moderate |
|
Limited Partnership |
At least one general partner and one or more limited partners. |
Partial |
Pass-Through |
Moderate |
Moderate |
|
Limited Liability Company (LLC) |
One or multiple owners (“members”). |
Yes |
Flexible |
Moderate |
Moderate |
|
C Corporation |
One or more shareholders (no max). |
Yes |
Double |
High |
High |
|
S Corporation |
Up to 100 shareholders |
Yes |
Pass-Through |
High |
High |
|
Nonprofit Corporation |
Members Not equity holders |
Yes |
Tax-exempt |
High |
High |
Selecting the right business structure is a crucial decision that will have long-lasting effects on your startup’s risk exposure, taxation, and ability to grow. There is no one-size-fits-all answer – the optimal choice depends on your specific business goals, the number of founders, plans for investment, and tolerance for administrative complexity.
When in doubt, it’s wise to consult with legal and tax professionals (and many times the SBA or SCORE mentors) before finalizing your choice. They can advise based on the latest laws and your particular circumstances. Keep in mind that your initial choice isn’t irreversible – businesses can and do change entity types (for example, upgrading from an LLC to a corporation as the company grows). But changing can be complicated and sometimes costly, so it’s better to get it right from the start if possible.
Before you make your final decision,. valuate each structure’s pros and cons through the lens of your startup’s needs: liability protection, tax efficiency, investment needs, and administrative capacity. This comprehensive understanding will guide you to a structure that supports your startup’s success while protecting you and aligning with your vision. With the knowledge from this guide and professional advice, you’ll be equipped to make an informed decision on how to legally structure your new venture – setting a solid foundation for growth and innovation
1 min read
Enzo O'Hara Garza : July 03, 2023
Have you ever looked under the hood of your car and marveled at how all those parts work together to get you from Point A to Point B? Your business's...
Enzo O'Hara Garza : April 19, 2020
After successfully processing nearly one hundred Paycheck Protection Program applications, we have some strong feelings about the program. Overall,...
Enzo O'Hara Garza : February 01, 2023
As a startup business, having the right accounting processes in place is essential for success. To get your accounting practices up and running...
